Wednesday, 24 July 2019

Even sound "fiscal and productivity" will never end our problems - need answers to No 1 problem, Zanu PF P Guramatunhu


"WE need appropriate fiscal policies, and so far government has done well and has squeezed money supply because there was too much government expenditure and it means that things are going to be tighter to a maximum of three years, and by then we should have done all painful activities and then go to a stage when things are going to normalise," Foreign Affairs minister Sibusiso Moyo has told the nation, as a matter of fact.

“Fundamentally, this economy's problems are hardly fiscal as Moyo seems to be alluding. Zimbabwe's problems are profoundly to do with productivity which is not being helped at all by the fiscal policies that President Emmerson Mnangagwa's regime is administering at the moment,” commented Newsday in its Editorial.

The Newsday Editor is 100% correct in dismissing Foreign Minister’s solution. Zimbabwe’s serious economic problems are not going to be solved by focusing of fiscal policies alone. Even if one gave the regime the benefit of the doubt and assume it was competent to replace the mishmash of confused and contradicting fiscal policies with sound and rational ones. A big IF!

However, the Editor is partly correct in suggesting Zimbabwe’s problems are “profoundly to do with productivity”. I will give the Editor the benefit of the doubt and assume such things as mismanagement and corruption, the twin cancers they have destroyed the Zimbabwe economy, are included in the productivity argument. Still this would not be enough to get Zimbabwe out of the economic mess we are stuck in.

Yes, of course, if Zimbabwe had sound and rational fiscal policies and we address all the needs to stimulate production and productivity the is no reason why the country’s economy should not recovery and prosper. The truth we must deal with here is that we are in this economic mess precisely because we have had mishmash fiscal policies, gross mismanagement, rampant corruption, etc., etc.

Worst of, whilst we have been aware of the need for sound fiscal policies, etc. and have complained about these economic impediments for the last 39 years; we have failed to get Zanu PF to listen much less change direction or even better still replace the regime.

Zanu PF has systematically eroded the people’s freedoms and rights including the right to have a meaningful say in the governance of the country. As long as Zanu PF retains its carte blanche dictatorial powers to rig elections, the regime will continue to impose its mishmash fiscal policies and ignore all calls to address the teething productivity problems.

“Is Moyo and his colleagues aware of all these hardships being faced by the very people, including labour, who they want help from to reboot this economy? From where they are comfortably perched, do they think that businesses, workers and farmers — barely managing to keep their heads above the water, will survive six months, let alone three years of these painful austerity measures?” continued Newsday Editorial.

“Three years is a very long time, Minister Moyo.”

In a country with unemployment a nauseating 90%; with a health care service that has all but collapsed; everyone suffering the ill effects of hyperinflation (second one after just ten years of first that saw inflation peak at 500 billion % and record devaluation, Z$ 35 quadrillion = US$1); etc. millions are drowning already. But let us put that aside.  

What is the point of asking Minister Moyo and his Zanu PF cronies whether the long-suffering ordinary Zimbabweans “will survive six months, let alone three years of these painful austerity measures?” We all know or should know the answer to that by now. The regime’s primary concern ever since it got into power 39 years ago was to establish a de facto one-party dictatorship and retain absolute power at all cost including denying the people their freedoms and rights including national economic ruin.

The question should be directed at the long-suffering Zimbabweans themselves; will they survive another six months let alone another three years of this economic meltdown? And more pointedly; even the most naïve and gullible must know that many will not survive and, at least some also know that at the end of the painful austerities there will be no gain; what are they going to do finally put an end to their 39 years and counting of political oppression and economic hardships?

The Genesis of Zimbabwe’s economic meltdown is not so much that we have an incompetent and corrupt Zanu PF regime that has failed to come up with sound fiscal policies and to stimulated productivity but that we have failed to remove it from office even we it was clear the regime was so corrupt and incompetent it was beyond the pale.

Nkrumah's slogan, “Seek ye first the political kingdom and all things shall be added unto you,” was Ghana’s first post independent President, Kwame Nkrumah’s clarion cry.  

For the last 39 years we have buried our head in the sand and ignored that Zanu PF usurped our individual freedoms and rights reducing us into no more than political serfs beholden to the regime. We have fooled ourselves into believe the country can ever achieve economic prosperity and still allow the corrupt, incompetent and tyrannical Zanu PF to enjoy absolute power.

We have paid dearly for our foolishness; Zimbabwe’s economy is in total meltdown after 39 years of Zanu PF misrule and the situation is getting worse not better. It is insane to let this madness continue for any longer.

It is clear Minister Moyo and his Zanu PF cronies have no clue what to do to end the worsening economic situation. The regime is in power but only because it rigged last year’s elections. It is illegitimate.

The people must reclaim their political power to remove a failed government and what better way to so just that than demanding that this illegitimate Zanu PF regime steps down.

We can pretend all we want that Zimbabwe’s economic problems will end if only we can get the Zanu PF regime to implement sound economic policies. Zanu PF itself is the number one problem, the regime’s “no regime change” mantra and blatant vote rigging are an unreconcilable afront to democratic elections and free and fair election as a key requirement of good governance. It is insane to keep hoping against reason and reality that the corrupt and incompetent Zanu PF will perform the miracles and revive the economy.  INSANE!

6 comments:

Patrick said...

So, MDC got 1/26 seats in parliament in Masvingo because MDC Provincial chair lives in Harare. Other than the two urban provinces of Harare and Bulawayo, MDC did not do well in any of the remaining 7 provinces; are we to infer from that none of the MDC provincial chairs live in the respective province!

Zanu PF rigged last year’s elections, denying 3 million Zimbabweans in the diaspora a vote, using traditional leaders and state supplied resources to reduce rural voters into serfs beholden to the party, etc., etc. We need to acknowledge and address these serious electoral flaws and illegalities if we are ever going to stop Zanu PF rigging elections.

Ruhanya’s foolish hyperbolical nonsense is typical of the feeble political excuse by the opposition to justify why they keep participating in flawed elections. In all his endless twittering, Pedzisai Ruhanya is yet to acknowledge that Zanu PF rigged last year’s elections and keeps coming up with all manner of farfetched reasons why Zanu PF “won” but fail to see the obvious one – Zanu PF rigged the elections. Such is the dubious intellectual ability of some of our people and it is little wonder the country is in a real mess.

Zimbabwe Light said...

@ Chihota

Why am I dismissing this document as old wine packaged in new wine skins? The MDC has since time immemorial been penning one blueprint or policy document after the other. Their latest offering, RELOAD joins other documents such as Agenda for Real Transformation (ART), Jobs, Upliftment, Investment, Capital and the Environment (JUICE), Plan and Environment and Credible Election (PEACE) and A Sustainable and Modernisation Agenda for Real Transformation (SMART) on the party's book cabinet.

Chamisa acknowledges that last year’s elections were illegal, not free and fair and thus making Zanu PF illegitimate. MDC is fraudulently offering to declare Zanu PF legitimate if Mnangagwa agrees to offer Chamisa and a few other MDC leaders cabinet positions. This is just a watered down version of the 2008 to 2013 GNU. It will not implement any reform just as the earlier one failed to do the same. “We sat and ate and accomplished nothing” Chamisa admitted last week; he just wants to do the same again.

The only way forward is for Zanu PF to step down to allow for the appointment of an interim administration that will finally implement the reforms and allow the country to move on!

Zimbabwe Light said...

This Zanu PF regime is incompetent and corrupt and hence the reason why the regime has failed to come up with any coherent economic policies and has blundered from pillar to post. But that the nation would have dealt with by now if it was not that the regime is able to rig elections and frustrate the people's democratic wish for meaningful change. It is the regime's carte blanche dictatorial powers to rig elections that makes Zanu PF the country's A1 problem.

As long as Zanu PF is free to rig elections and stay in power the country is stuck with the corrupt, incompetent and murderous thugs as leaders and whatever policies they decide to follow regardless how stupid and disastrous the policies happen to be. For the last 39 years the people of Zimbabwe have allowed Zanu PF to rig elections and get away with it.

It is shocking how many Zimbabwe have resolutely avoided answering the question was last year's elections free, fair and credible. Many have even elected to answer in the affirmative just to avoid having to deal with the nagging question of how many times they are going to allow Zanu PF to rig elections and get away with it. The tragic consequences of 39 years of Zanu PF misrule is the economic ruins and over 30 000 murdered by the regime and hundreds of thousands is not millions beaten and/or raped for the sole purpose of creating and retaining the dictatorship.

The root cause of Zimbabwe's economic and political problems is the the Zanu PF dictatorship, and after 39 years of burying our heads in the sand and pretend we can still solve all our national problem and let Zanu PF do as it pleased we cannot do this any more!

Zanu PF is the country's number one problem and we must deal with it! NOW!

Zimbabwe Light said...



It is laughable that we have a regime that rigs elections, denies millions of its own people the basic freedoms and rights, and it then spends a fortune paying PR and lobby groups to falsify its human rights record. Still no one can change the reality of the economic meltdown! “It is the economy, stupid that will force this regime to accept change!

Nomusa Garikai said...

After 39 years of expecting the Zanu PF miracle economic mass prosperity as the nation sunk deeper and deeper into mass poverty, one would think Zimbabweans had learned their lesson by now! Zanu PF is corrupt and incompetent and the only reason the party is still in power is because it rigs elections. This is why implement the reforms to stop the vote rigging is the battle royal, nothing of substance will ever be accomplished until we end this curse of rigged elections.

Nomusa Garikai said...

@ Simon Taylor

“If substantial change is desired in Zimbabwe, then the time has come to stop treating the country as a democracy, flawed or otherwise, and view it as a military dictatorship with a thin civilian veneer,” you said.

“The civilian control over armed and security forces is arguably the most crucial, yet least appreciated aspect of democracy. The simple reason is that, as RJ Rummel so conclusively demonstrated in Death By Government, states kill more of their own citizens than any other factor save for natural disasters. No number of violence-free elections can guarantee a democracy as long as a military is not subject to parliamentary oversight.”

You are absolutely right, Zanu PF has effected a near perfect state capture so that the key state institutions like the Army, Police, Judiciary, etc. are but departments of Zanu PF in all but name. The irony is that other than the top ruling elite the rest are not benefiting from the corrupt and tyrannical waste of the country’s human and material resources. Even the filthy rich ruling elite have not escaped the ill effect of nation wide power cuts, collapsed health services, etc.

Some of the senior securocrats, judges politicians, etc. cannot afford a democratic Zimbabwe in which Zanu PF is booted out of political power because they fear losing their looted wealth and worse still fear justice because they have shed innocent blood.

Zimbabwe had the golden opportunity during the GNU to implement the democratic reforms to dismantle the Zanu PF dictatorship and its surrogate bodies including the Army, Police, Judiciary, etc. It is sad that this opportunity was wasted, MDC failed to implement even one reform in five years. Not one!

Worse still, many Zimbabweans have yet to realize that MDC has been running with the hare and hunting with the hounds, even now with the benefit of hindsight.

If there are a people who deserve the government they have it is Zimbabweans. We sure deserve this corrupt, incompetent and tyrannical Zanu PF dictatorship complete with its entourage of equally corrupt and incompetent MDC opposition.