Thursday 5 July 2018

"No reform, not elections!" Chamisa threatened - not bluffing, wheels are flying off the bullet train P Guramatunhu

Chamisa threatens to withdraw from the elections; he has bluffed in the past but this time events beyond his control are force him to withdraw - the wheels are flying off the Chamisa bullet train!

MDC leaders have been their own worst enemy with their double talk. It is all very well rattling the party’s red-line reform demands and insisting “there will be no elections unless our demands are met; but we will not boycott the elections”, to their simpleton MDC supporters. The later have always followed like sheep to the slaughter, no questions asked. It is different matter rattling the same nonsense to the many international elections observers now in the country.

After patiently asking the MDC leaders to explain what exactly this double Dutch meant in practice and getting no sensible answer; the observers must have rightly concluded that MDC leaders were just a bunch of pretenders posturing with no clue what they were doing.

How can anyone with even half a brain agree to take part in an election process with no free public media, no clean and verified voters’ roll, etc. The very fact that MDC leaders and the rest of the opposition candidates were doing so has forced the observers questioning the sanity of these politicians.

In June 2013, just a month before that year’s Zimbabwe elections, SADC leaders wanted the elections postponed because they were convinced Zanu PF was going to rig the vote. “If you take part in next month’s elections, you will lose; the elections are done!” they warned Morgan Tsvangirai and his MDC friends.

If the international election observers would repeat the same warning if they believed anyone in the opposition camp would listen.

Still, it is what the international observers are going to do next that finally got attention of Zimbabwe’s opportunistic opposition politicians. With no such basic requirement as free media, no clean and verified voters’ roll, etc. it is as clear as day that the international observers are going to condemn these flawed elections and declare the process null and void.

Of course, MDC leaders have gone into these elections knowing that with no reforms in place Zanu PF was going to rig the elections. Still, they joined the rat race regardless, because they also knew that to make the process look credible Zanu PF was giving away a few gravy train seats. It is these bait seats they are after, as David Coltart, MDC senator and Minister in the GNU, readily admitted in his book.

“The worst aspect for me about the failure to agree a coalition was that both MDCs couldn’t now do the obvious – withdraw from the (2013) elections,” explained Senator Coltart. 

“The electoral process was so flawed, so illegal, that the only logical step was to withdraw, which would compel SADC to hold Zanu PF to account. But such was the distrust between the MDC-T and MDC-N that neither could withdraw for fear that the other would remain in the elections, winning seats and giving the process credibility.”

But with the international community now set to declare the process null and void, the MDC leaders know the few gravy train seats will be of no value.

Worst of all, being named as one of the opportunistic opposition candidates who participated in the sham elections will be curse that will force one to take early retirement from politics. A savvy political opponent in future races will remind the electorate that participating in the sham elections one had helped to give the flawed electoral process credibility and to forfeit the nation’s chance to bring about real political changed.

If these elections are declared null and void, the country will be forced to revisit the raft of democratic reforms agreed in the 2008 GNU and, this time, get the reforms implemented. It will be tough enough to survive in a new open and democratic political dispensation; it will be impossible to do so for anyone with the albatross round their neck of having sold out by participating in the sham past elections. This is a political reality is dawning even in the sloth-minded ones in Morgan Tsvangirai House, MDC Alliance HQ.

If there are no gravy train seats to be had then boycotting these elections even at this the eleventh hour and, hopefully, get rid of the albatross makes a lot of sense. The scramble to be the MDC candidate of two weeks ago may very quickly turn into rout as opposition candidates withdraw from the race!

As MDC leaders lose the little political credibility they still had the Chamisa bullet train express will lose its wheels, as election candidates withdraw, followed by many of its simpleton passengers, even they know a train with no wheels will go nowhere!

15 comments:

Nomusa Garikai said...

Chamisa writes to ZEC requesting a meeting to discuss a list of MDC demands.

Even if this meeting was to be granted and everything requested in this letter was granted; would this make this election free, fair and credible? the honest answer to that question has to be a no!

There is lot more to free, fair and credible elections than the layout of the ballot papers and messaging individual candidate like Chamisa's hot-air balloon size ego. Millions of Zimbabweans have been denied the vote by the simple act of ZEC failing to give all those of its targeted 7 million voters reasonable time to register because BVR was started very, very late. There is no hope of producing a clean and verified voters' roll now just weeks before voting.

This list of demands is just another one of the MDC's time-wasting gimmicks that the people of Zimbabwe and the international election observers must dismiss with the contempt it rightly deserves.

MDC leaders have been advised 100 000 times and 100 000 times again not to take part in these elections without first implementing the reforms. We are in this mess because Chamisa and company will not listen.

These elections should not be taking place without first implementing the reform. Now that we have been dragged into this mess, the best course of action is to just declare these flawed and illegal elections null and void.

Zimbabwe Light said...

Chamisa has lost a lot of political credibility by insisting in taking part in these elections with no reforms in place. He could fool and bamboozle his naive and gullible MDC supporters but not the international election observers. They are not impressed with all these foolish gimmicks! They are used to people who make a demand and stand firm or else shut up and none of this up and down like a yo-yo!

Zimbabwe Light said...

Speaking during the launch of the Zimcode Trust, an organisation that is championing improved corporate governance, Sibanda, a long time Mugabe bureaucrat, said the new political dispensation led by President Emmerson Mnangagwa had upped its efforts to confront the scourge.

"It is indeed a sad fact that corruption has become a major problem within Zimbabwe and is stubbornly entrenched within both the private and the public sectors," he said.

"Government is very much alive to this evil and it is ramping up its efforts to confront the challenges posed by decades of what can only be termed an unhealthy tolerance of highly-questionable practices and lack of consequential sanction for those involved in corrupt practices and even those identified as corrupt."

Dr Sibanda, it is naïve to think that those who have benefited from corruption all these years will have a sudden Damascene moment, out of the blue with no pressure from outside, to stop corruption and go ahead and stop it. Even if they recognise how damaging corruption has been to the nation the best one can ever expect from the individuals concerned is to reduce corrupt and sanitize the reminder.

How can Mnangagwa and Chiwenga end corruption when they are themselves two of the fat cats whose amassed wealth was earned from corruption?

If we are serious about ending corruption then we must have leaders who are democratically accountable to the victims of corruption and know that if they do not uproot corruption as promised then others who will, will be elected to do it.

Patrick said...

ZDF has been involved in the wanton violence of 2008 and 2013 and stage a coup only eight months ago and we are to take Mungwisi's word that it is a professional army that up holds the law. How naive!

Patrick said...

You should be concerned about whether the elections are free, fair and credible because no investor will want to do business in a pariah state ruled by vote rigging thugs! As it turns out Zanu PF is rigging these elections!

Patrick said...

Zimbabwe's failure to have a healthy and functional political system can be attribute to three centres:
1) Zanu PF
The party has used its liberation war platform to impose a corrupt and tyrannical de facto one party dictatorship. The regime is now sold to the idea that it has the divine right to rule Zimbabwe until kingdom come regardless of its pathetic record of misrule and murder

2) MDC opposition
The MDC had the best opportunities to end the Zanu PF dictatorship but has wasted them all. MDC leaders have never had the confidence to rule Zimbabwe without Zanu PF's blessing and hence the reason the party has always sort ways of accommodating Zanu PF even when they had the opportunity to dismantle the dictatorship.

3) The people
The people have never had an real chance to assert their freedoms and basic human rights, the white colonial regime had treated them as third class citizens and Zanu PF wanted the system to continue. It took 20 years or so for the people to actively seek a more just political system. They risked life and limb to elect MDC into power but only to be betrayed. The people have never bothered to understand the detail of the democratic changes they wanted and making it easy for MDC people to sell-out on reforms.

The need to open up the country's media and freedom of expression are of the greatest importance and urgency. We need an informed electorate if we are ever going to have a healthy and functional democratic system of government.

Patrick said...

FRAUD accused former Energy Minister, Samuel Undenge went ballistic and demanded President Emmerson Mnangagwa’s arrest as he took to the dock Wednesday to defend claims of prejudicing the Zimbabwe Power Company (ZPC) of $12,000 during his tenure.
Undenge emotionally took it to the witness stand where he claimed he was being persecuted for belonging to the infamous G40 faction which was once fiercely opposed to Mnangagwa succeeding then President Robert Mugabe.
He called for Mnangagwa’s arrest saying the now State leader was the one who directed Fruitful Communications Company, which is at the centre of the fraud storm, to do public relations for ZPC without going to tender.
The ex-minister said his prosecution was a clear mockery to the country’s justice system considering that “corrupt individuals” were walking scot free while he was being pursued over $12,000.
“An official from the president’s office, Ndlukula testified in this court that Vice President’s wife, Marry Chiwenga was given a contract without going to tender, for a company which did not even exist.
“The company was even named when authorities decided to favour her with the deal because it never existed.
“It was a multimillion dollar deal but procedures were not followed; that is outright corruption,” he said.
“It also baffles me that owners of Fruitful Communications, Oscar Pambuka and Psychology Maziwisa clearly indicated that they were instructed to do PR work by the (now) President but the Zimbabwe Anti-Corruption Commission (ZACC) has never made any effort to record a statement from him.
“That is why I insist that am being persecuted for political reasons and I ask this court to acquit me because I did not commit any offence.”
Yes Mr Undenge, you are being singled out because you are G40 member as for the amount you are being accused of looting I have a feeling that $12 000 is only the start. The regime has promised to stamp out corruption and after eight months in office has yet to come up with some results. You, Mr Undenge are one of the few success story the regime needs. Bad luck or call it what you will!

Patrick said...

SADC know that turning a blind eye to Zanu PF vote rigging in 2013 was a big mistake since that did not bring economic recovery, the Zimbabwe Stock Exchange index fell 35% when result came out, or political stability, Zanu PF factional wars intensified leading to the November 2017 coup, as we now know. The bomb blast last Saturday reminded everyone that Zanu PF's internal fighting is still on the cards.

By declaring these elections null and void SADC will have a second chance to end the Zimbabwe crisis, a second bite of the cherry, and they will be really foolish if they did not make it count.

When Mugabe realised Zimbabwe was going to be booted out of the commonwealth he pre-empted the move by resigning. I believe MDC leaders are going to do the same. As soon as if become clear the international community are going to declare these elections null and void MDC leaders will pre-empty the move by withdrawing from the election under the pretext Zanu PF and ZEC did not implement the reforms they had asked for.

Know MDC as we do they will even start calling for the international community to declare the elections null and void so when they do MDC leaders can claim the credit.

Patrick said...

SADC has more to lose from the continued economic chaos and political instability in Zimbabwe than anyone else. The regional body did not lose anything by declaring the 2008 elections null and void. Instead they got the golden opportunity to get Zimbabwe back on a more stable path, if only MDC had implemented the reforms. By declaring these elections null and void they will give Zimbabwe another chance.

President Mnangagwa will have only himself to blame for the decision to declare the election null and void, just as did Mugabe in 2008; he promised free and fair elections and failed to deliver. It will not be only SADC saying this; the whole world will be saying the same. Not even the Chinese and Russians would want to be seen to say the elections were free and fair in the face of all this evidence. in 2008 they said nothing and they will do the same again.

Patrick said...

In an open message at Westminster, May answered the chair of the parliamentary portfolio committee on Zimbabwe, HON. Kate Hoey saying, “I say to the honourable Lady, I commend the excellent work that she does .. she continues to do as chair of the APPG on Zimbabwe and obviously we welcome the announcement of the date of the election the 30th July but we are urging all parties involved to pursue free and fair, peaceful elections, cause that I think that is what the Zimbabwean people deserve and we will certainly trade carefully to see how those elections are conducted and consider obviously the conduct of those elections as appropriate.

“And we have repeatedly said if the Zimbabwean government can demonstrate commitment to political and economic reform then the UK stands ready to do all it can to support its recovery. But obviously that commitment is essential.”

Sadly that commitment to democratic reform has been noticeably lacking because these elections are going ahead with not even one reform in place. There is no free public media. ZEC has failed to register nearly 22% of the targeted 7 million because there was no time to do so as the BVR was started very late. ZEC has failed to produce a clean and verified voters’ roll; etc. etc. There is no way these elections can ever be deemed free, fair and credible. No way!

All the people of Zimbabwe are asking for, have been dying for, is free, fair and credible elections – that is not too much to ask of their government. If President Mnangagwa and his regime cannot deliver free and fair elections as the promised then they must step aside to allow the appointment of an interim administration that will hold free and fair elections. After 38 years of rigged elections the people of Zimbabwe are not going to accept yet another rigged election! No way!

Patrick said...

@ tafirenyika

The British wanted to let Mnangagwa off the hook, they are only now saying the right thing.

What is wrong with saying Zimbabwe must hold free, fair and credible elections? Your foolishness is coming through!

Patrick said...

“The EU EOM conducts a comprehensive and impartial analysis of the whole electoral process!” EU promises.

President Mnangagwa has promised to hold free, fair and credible elections – after 38 years of rigged elections corrupt and tyrannical rule, one can imagine how desperate the nation is to see this finally happen.

It is the ardent wish of every long suffering Zimbabwean that these elections are free, fair and credible. However, given the nation’s history of rigged elections, if these elections are once again rigged; it is our fervent wish that the elections are declared null and void and something is done to end this scourge.

If these elections are not free and fair, please say so because what we do not want is another fudge! We do not want another whitewashed flawed election process!

The good people of Zimbabwe welcome the EU and all the foreign election observer teams. We wish you well and hope and pray that your work will help us the most intractable problem that has weighed this nation down like a mile’s stone round our neck for the last 38 years!

All the people of Zimbabwe want is free, fair and credible elections that many others the world over take for granted.

Patrick said...

The international observers are being invited to say whether these elections are free and fair and, given what we can see already, they are going to give a thumbs down and this is why ED supporters are getting jumpy already.

Patrick said...

The international observers do not need lessons from Chamisa on what constitute free and fair elections and they certainly do not agree with Chamisa's foolish posturing. Only a first class fool will be a clean and verified voters' roll this late in the election process for example. If anything, the observers are disappointed with the sheer incompetence of the MDC and are completely ignoring that lot!

Patrick said...

The EU, Americans and most of the international observer KNOW what constitutes free and fair elections and they are certainly not going to be influenced in any way by Chamisa's idiotic blaundering. Their decision will be more rational than Chamisa's "MDC win the elections were free anf fair and if the part blose the elections were rigged!"