"Legitimacy is an issue - last year's elections were illegal, and not free and fair. All reasonable observers concede that," admitted David Coltart, MDC Alliance Treasurer General. It has taken almost a year for the party to finally admit the elections were rigged.
What some people may not know is that Coltart and his MDC A friends KNEW the elections would be rigged but they still participated in the elections regardless. Why? Greed, plain and simple, as Coltart himself confessed in his book.
In his Book, The Struggle Continues 50 years of tyranny in Zimbabwe, former MDC – Ncube Senator and Minister of Education in the GNU, David Coltart, gave details of how Zanu PF flouted the electoral rules, it was clear the upcoming 2013 elections would not be free and fair. And yet the two MDC factions still participated in the elections regardless, blaming the decision on the failure by the two factions to form a coalition.
“The worst aspect for me about the failure to agree a coalition was that both MDCs couldn’t now do the obvious – withdraw from the elections,” he stated.
“The electoral process was so flawed, so illegal, that the only logical step was to withdraw, which would compel SADC to hold Zanu PF to account. But such was the distrust between the MDC-T and MDC-N that neither could withdraw for fear that the other would remain in the elections, winning seats and giving the process credibility.”
Blaming the failure to form a coalition for participating in elections they all knew were flawed and illegal was just a feeble excuse. The real reason for participating was greed. They all knew Zanu PF was throwing away a few gravy train seats as bait to entice the opposition to participate; they could not resist the bait.
Three of the main MDC factions did form the coalition just before last year’s election, they all knew Zanu PF would still rig the elections since not even one reform was ever implemented since the 2013 elections and yet they still participated for the same reason as before - greed.
It has taken nearly a year for MDC A to finally admit last year’s elections were “illegal and not free and fair” and so outcome is illegal and those assuming power, be there from the ruling party or the opposition, on the basis of the illegal elections are ipso facto illegitimate.
So, what is the way forward?
"It is also no use relying on the Constitutional Court judgment because any lawyer worth his or her salt will explain how fundamentally flawed both the procedure and judgment were. So, in a dialogue it is unhelpful trying to argue that a discredited process must just be accepted,” proposed Coltart.
"I would just add, we need a dialogue arbitrated by a neutral democratic peer. We cannot have one person, who even on his own figures, in a fraudulent unconstitutional election, won by a tiny margin, dictate the terms, pace, venue and structure of the dialogue."
No, how can we have those guilty of high treason of holding “a fraudulent and unconstitutional elections”, Zanu PF for organising the elections and MDC A for knowingly participating in the illegal elections, dictate the way forward!
Yes, legitimacy is the BIG ISSUE in Zimbabwe. Since last year’s elections were illegal and not free and fair, the country does NOT have a legitimate government as of the 1 st August 2018. The idea of Zanu PF and MDC A, even with the help of a neutral democratic peer can continue to usurp the people’s power and fundamental right to a meaningful say in the governance of the country by conferring legitimacy on themselves is any abomination. It is the people of Zimbabwe alone in a free, fair and credible elections confer legitimacy.
Even if one was to overlook the patronising and political arrogance and contempt with which both Zanu PF and MDC A leaders have treated the ordinary Zimbabweans throughout these last 39 years; one cannot ignore the political reality that the political dialogue proposed by the two parties will not deliver free, fair and credible elections. The two parties were in the last GNU in 2008 to 2013 and they failed to implement even one meaningful democratic reform, it is naïve to expect the two to do any better the second time round.
Even if not even one reform was implemented MDC A leaders would participate in the 2023 elections regardless for the same reason they participated in the 2013 and 2018 elections – greed. Why would Zanu PF implement any reforms and risk losing the elections when the party KNOWS that the MDC A will participate in the elections regardless how flawed and illegal process as long as Zanu PF offers the bait gravy train seats.
Now it is finally agreed last July’s elections were illegal, and not free and fair then both Zanu PF and MDC A must know they are both illegitimate and must step down. The nation must be allowed the political space and time to appoint an interim administration that will be tasked to finally implement the raft of democratic reforms agreed at the on-set of the 2008 GNU.
Zimbabwe history will record that Zanu PF established the de facto one-party dictatorship that has ruled the country with an iron fist these last 39 years with disastrous consequences. History will also note that MDC leaders wasted many golden opportunities to implement the democratic reforms and end the Zanu PF dictatorship. Even with the nation’s very existence on the line still it took MDC leaders a year to admit the 2018 elections were illegal. One only hopes that MDC leaders will not give Zanu PF any more excuses for refusing to step down.
Zimbabwe’s next elections must be free, fair and credible and the people’s freedoms and rights fully restored – that is not too much to ask!
4 comments:
@ Terence Charsley
“What you should be saying is plan for 2023, while we continue watching the circus unfold,” you said.
You and me and millions of other ordinary Zimbabweans out there we have all been watching the circus unfold for the last 39 years. Initially it was Robert Mugabe and his Zanu PF thugs as they rod roughshod over our freedoms and rights to establish the de facto one party dictatorship that has ruled the nation since independence in 1980. The regime has all but destroyed the nation’s economy forcing millions of us into poverty and those lucky enough to escape have done so.
Since 1999, many of us have risked life and limb to elect Morgan Tsvangirai and his MDC friends in the ticket they would implement the democratic reforms necessary to dismantle the Zanu PF dictatorship and restore our individual freedoms and rights including the right to free, fair and credible elections. They had many golden opportunities to get this done but failed to do so because they are corrupt and incompetent.
With unemployment at 90%, with health care all but collapsed, 19 hours power cuts, etc. it is clear that Zimbabwe at the edge of the precipice. It is therefore shocking, to say the least, that anyone out there would be content “to continue watching the circus”!
If we do not anything to make sure the democratic reforms to stop Zanu PF rigging the elections are implemented then, of course, the 2023 will be rigged again. The circus will continue alright!
@Stan Dube
“Your politics is commenting..why don’t you participate by fielding your own. Don’t you know that they will always field pseudo parties and legitimise the process..please spare us that dramma” you said.
After 39 years of “participating” and the country sinking deeper and deeper into despair and poverty there is surely a crying need for thorough investigation to establish why we are in this mess.
In last year’s elections there were no fewer than 130 political parties, that did not produce a good and competent government. So why you think having more political parties is the answer beggars belief! You are just obsessed with quantity. Having more political parties will not solve our problems, it is quality we want.
Unemployment is a nauseating 90%, there is 19 hours a day load shedding, health care has all but collapsed, etc., etc. What more drama do you want? “Spare us that drama!” Yeah right! Why have you not asked Zanu PF and MDC leaders to do that; they are the ones causing it all not me!
@ Tshetshe Ndlovu
“Zanu PF will never voluntarily step down and go to prison for crimes committed against humanity let alone the gravy train they are in, it’s a dream,” you say.
This is the worst kind of defeatism – the kind where one shoots himself in both legs just to be absolutely certain one loses the race!
You ever said that Zanu PF will “voluntarily step down”? Would you do so if you were a seasoned corrupt, incompetent and murderous tyrant like Mnangagwa or any of the other Zanu PF thugs? Of course, not! So, why are you wasting time and energy talking of an outcome that not even an idiot would consider.
Zanu PF rigged the 2008 elections and MDC were quick off the mark in condemning the elections, Tsvangirai withdraw from the race for Pete’s sake. The international community, including AU and SADC who are renowned for approving dodgy elections, too condemn the elections and would not accept Zanu PF’s claim as the legitimately elected government.
Zanu PF was forced to give up its legitimacy claim, sign 2008 Global Political Agreement in which the party would share power in GNU and to agree to the implementation of the raft of democratic reforms to dismantle the Zanu PF dictatorship. Mugabe did not volunteer to do these things, he was forced!
Now that it is agreed that last year’s elections were “illegal, and not free and fair”. (MDC A would have endorsed the elections as free, fair and credible a long time ago if Mnangagwa had played ball and given Chamisa and a few others in MDC A cushy gravy train seats complete with ministerial limos, generous salaries, etc.) This puts Zimbabwe back in the same situation as in 2008, we have no legitimate government.
Instead of forcing Zanu PF to agree into yet another power sharing arrangement, which is what Chamisa and his MDC A friends are demanding, we must demand that Zanu PF steps down!
The reality of the worsening economic meltdown will pile on the pressure for Zanu PF to step down. In the end, Zanu PF will step down! Even with all your defeatists negativity; Zanu PF will step down. It is just a matter of when and not if!
"Fortune Chasi, propaganda will not take this country anywhere. On Wednesday in Parliament you talked about government paying $10m to Eskom after I asked about the power crisis in this country. So, where is the money then?” said MDC A MP Mamombe.
Why Chasi made the stupid statement with no proof that the money was paid only goes to show how incompetent our leaders are!
Post a Comment