Thursday 21 June 2018

ZEC has failed to produce a verified voters' roll, depend on MDC to give a stupid response N Garikai

“The one dependable thing about the Italians, is that they are undependable!” Adolf Hitler reportedly said of his ally in sheer exasperation!

To paraphrase Hitler, “The one dependable thing about MDC Alliance is that they will do something utterly stupid!” And true enough, the MDC leaders have never disappointed on this score!

The nomination Courts sat last Thursday, 14th June, to process and produce the definitive list of all these wishing to contest for the president, over 200 parliamentary seats, 89 senatorial seats and the hundreds of local government council seats in this year’s harmonised elections. The whole process was nothing but an Alice in Wonderland theatrical farce!

Each of the aspiring candidate is supposed to be nominated by 100 registered voters in the constituency and this is one of the things the Court officials were there to check and confirm. It turns out that the aspiring candidate were never given the voters’ roll and so they must have collected three or more as many nominees and hope 100 will be in the voters’ roll. It is not surprising that a number of aspiring candidates failed to get target figure.

One assumes that the Court officials themselves had a voters’ roll!

The law is very clear on the voters’ roll; ZEC is legally obliged to release a verified voters’ roll at least one month before nomination day. It is inconceivable that none of the magistrates or judges who presided over the nomination process, there were three or four Nomination Courts in each of the country’s ten provinces, and yet not even one of these “learned” men and women were aware that ZEC had failed to produce a verified voters’ roll timeously. Worse still, that they, like it or not, were presiding and thus giving credibility to what is clearly an illegal and farcical process.

How can the sworn custodians of the law blindly enforce one section of law, that all aspiring candidate must be nominated by 100 voters, but turn a blind eye to the blatant violation of the presenting section of same law without which the later section makes no sense? It is ZEC who should be punished for failing to produce a verified voters’ roll and not aspiring candidates. And so, it came to pass that on 14th June we Nomination Courts presiding over a process one would only associate with the Alice in Wonderland theatrical court.

ZEC has since released the voters’ roll with one caveat, the elections will go ahead regardless how serious the irregularities people find in the voters’ roll.

“The Zimbabwe Electoral Commission has failed to meet its legal and constitutional obligation to provide election materials timely with reference to the voters roll and as such it owes the people of Zimbabwe an apology rather than a mouthful of arrogance by suggesting that if they are any anomalies in the voters roll we should stomach it and raise any complaints after the election and that only an earthquake will stop the election,” wrote Jameson Timba a senior MDC leader and election agent to MDC Alliance presidential candidate, Nelson Chamisa.

This is MDC leaders doing what they do best, shoot themselves in the foot. The issue of making sure there is a verified voters’ roll is even more serious than failing to produce one before nomination day. How can these elections be free, fair and credible when people who should be on the roll are not those who should not be are, for example? In the 2013 elections, nearly one million voters were denied the vote because their details were posted in the wrong constituency. God only knows how many valid multiple votes the hooded Zanu PF supporters bussed from one polling station to the next casted that year.

It is nonsensical to say serious irregularities in the voters’ roll must be raised after the elections, to what end and purpose since the result will not change. What Timba thinks the ZEC apology will accomplish is a complete mystery! He could not have come up with anything more foolish to say than that!

“We’ve now established that the voters roll ZEC is issuing is not the final roll. Those who ‘registered’ during inspection are yet to be added. ZEC claims it will add them later,” commented Nelson Chamisa on his facebook page.

“So ZEC has given us a voters’ roll it knows is not final. Our response is coming, it will be red.”

The inspection of the provisional voters’ roll was 19 to 29th May 2018. There could not have been a few hundred thousand new voters who registered in those ten days and given there are over 10 000 polling stations and voting is strictly by polling station there will be one page of supplementary voters on each polling station. So, why is ZEC opting to produce a new voters’ roll, given it has laboured to produce the one it has just realised?

What matters here is that the voters’ roll ZEC will be using on voting day will be totally different from the roll now in circulation and, worst of all, the final roll will not be realised! So, here we go again, we are going into an election in which we, the electorate, have no clue who is in the voters’ roll, who will vote and how many times, etc.

The more one looks at these flawed and illegal elections the more shambolic and comical the whole process looks. ZEC alone has spent nearly $100 million dollars in preparing for these elections and Zanu PF, the big spender, has squandered over $4 billion; we are the poorest nation in Africa but, by Jove, we do love our farcical theatricals.

These elections are a farce and a criminal waste of time, space and treasure; President Mnangagwa should have been told in no uncertain terms that there will be no elections not until all the democratic reforms agreed at the onset of the 2008 GNU have been implemented and thus guarantee free, fair and credible elections.


“Our response is coming, it will be red!” Comes the dependably foolish opposition. Even if the MDC finally walk out of these flawed and illegal election process, one has to ask why it has taken forever before the penny finally dropped!!!

6 comments:

Zimbabwe Light said...

ZEC has just failed to produce a verified voters' roll, where in the world has it been possible to hold free, fair and credible elections with no verified voters' roll? In third world countries, with very weak public institutions organisations like the UN and their officials have always tended to side with the rich and powerful knowing no one will ever hold them to accord.

"We met with the head of the Zimbabwe Electoral Commission [Priscilla Chigumba]. We were given a comprehensive briefing. An encouraging briefing," said U.N. Assistant Secretary-General for Political Affairs Tayé-Brook Zerihoun. "Certainly there are issues to be handled and discussed. There is a positive pre-disposition - in my personal reading - in the way things are going. But at the end of the day the UN agenda is to help countries in their efforts to have as inclusive, transparent, free and fair elections as possible so that the outcome truly reflects the will of the people and therefore accept by all."

And you serious think that "these issues to be handled and discussed" can be meaningful resolved now six weeks before the elections when nothing has been done in the last five years? How naïve and gullible some of these buffoons can be!

After 38 years of gross mismanagement and rampant corruption that has pushed unemployment to the dizzying height of 90% and left ¾ of our people living on US$1.00 a day, Zimbabwe cannot afford another rigged election and more of this misrule. Buffoons like Tayé-Brook Zerihoun can afford to be naïve the people of Zimbabwe cannot!

Zimbabwe Light said...

ZEC is obliged by law to produce a verified voters' roll a month before nomination day at the latest, ZEC cannot be selective in which laws the commission will follow and which it will ignore.

Zimbabwe Light said...

With no reforms in place Zanu PF is set to rig these elections.

Zimbabwe is in this economic mess because for the last 38 years the nation was stuck with a regime that rigged elections to stay in power. The single most important issue before us therefore is to end this tradition of rigged elections.

The next government must be elected by the people in a free, fair and credible elections. If Zanu PF cannot keep its promise to hold free and fair elections then they must step aside and allow other who will.

Zimbabwe Light said...

MDC agree Zanu PF is rigging these elections and has been rigging elections in the past. SADC leaders are on record advising Morgan Tsvangirai and the other MDC leaders not to take part in rigged elections and yet they still di not want to listen.

Zanu PF people have already publicly admitted that they will not reform themselves out of office. In other words, they have the carte blanche powers to rig elections and they have no intention of giving up these powers.

By participating in flawed and illegal elections MDC are giving the process the modicum of credibility. Zanu Pf has learned that as long as they dangle a few gravy train seats they will have no problem of attracting the opposition to contest the flawed elections.

The key question is: When will MDC leaders stop selling-out and end their madness?

In the light of MDC intransgency the people of Zimbabwe are best advised to ignore MDC duplicity and demand that theseflawed and illegal elections must be declared null and void.

Zimbabwe Light said...

@ Yeukai Mutumwa

We should not forget that President Mnangagwa and his junta regime is illegitimate as it was born out of a military coup. When the regime promised to hold free, fair and credible elections it was a desperate effort to recoup some legitimacy by promising to return to legitimacy. After 38 years of rigging elections to secure power the regime was certainly not going to give up it dictatorial carte blanche powers and risk losing power in a free and fair elections. So, the regime promised the free and fair elections with a nod and wink!

President Mnangagwa has not even made a token attempt to implement any democratic reforms necessary for free and fair elections. Indeed, he has continued implementing the vote rigging plans Zanu PF has used in the past with great success such as bribing the Chiefs to campaign for the party. President Mnangagwa has bought each of the country's 282 Chiefs twin cab Isuzu truck which Mugabe had promised to do before he was forced to resign during the coup.

President Mnangagwa and his junta know exactly what they want, to rig these elections and stay in power at all cost. However, to get off the illegitimate hook, they just need to bribe MDC politicians to play along and give the impression the elections were free and fair. The MDC leaders have already shown that they are corrupt and incompetent and offered the right bribe they will do as they are told which, as we can see, is happening here.

Zimbabwe Light said...

I agree with you there, it is indeed inconceivable that not even one of the 40 or so magistrates and judges who presided over the nomination process did not know the basic fact that ZEC had made the voters' roll available to the prospective candidate. And yet they had all religiously demanded that all nomination forms must have the 100 names of registered voters. If anything, the incident proves beyond all reasonable doubt that our judiciary, just like ZEC itself, is in the pocket of the regime.

Other than the British who have tried to down play the failure by ZEC to realise the voters' roll in time by letting it known, that their Embassy staff have a copy, I am sure all the other international elections observers have seen this just as another big stumbling block to ensure these elections are not free and fair. With no verified voters' roll there is no knowing who is registered to vote, where they are supposed to go, etc. there is no doubt that hundreds of thousands will be denied the vote. In the ensuing chaos there will be opportunities for favoured ones to cast multiple votes!

Zanu PF are like a crocodile, it hunts best in muddy waters; both the fish and crocodile cannot see each other but it does not care about that since it relies on the fish blundering into its open jaws.

The sheer blundering stupidity of the MDC and their opposition friends have provided a smokescreen for Zanu PF to hide its vote rigging. One hopes that the international community have seen enough of the MDC's foolishness to know they are corrupt and incompetent and have lost political credibility ages ago.

The international community must judge these elections null and void because the whole process has become a shambles farce!