Friday 18 July 2014

What does Mugabe but more significantly the nation want out of GNU 2?

“If you see a frog hopping in the midday heat as if his very life depends on each hop, you can be sure something is after him and his life is indeed on the line!” I wrote in my last piece.

In it I went on to show by accepting to have talks with every “including the opposition and civic society” as Zanu PF spokesman Rugare Gumba say, Mugabe was leaving the political security of absolute power he had secured by rigging the July 2013 elections to form another GNU he had shown nothing but contempt for. This was Mugabe hopping in the midday heat as if his very life depended on each hop because something was after him!

The danger threatening Mugabe was the reality that he had failed to rig economic recovery. The consequence of this failure was the empty ZimAsset begging bowl that remained mockingly empty, a year after the plan was launched. But worse still the failure to rig economic recovery had resulted in a dangerous economic nose dive and poverty has spread everywhere like a plague more virile and ruthless than ever. He has brought havoc amount the poor dragging them into greater depths of economic misery and despair. Poverty, that rogue, has no respect for chefs either!

Poverty has walking into the homes of Zanu PF grandees like the late Nathan Shamuyarira without even knocking. He has been living in abject poverty for years and he died a pauper. Zanu PF cynically painted his house the day he died to hide the years of neglect, rot and decay.

Poverty is spreading so fast and he is on first name friendly basis with everyone across the political divide in Zimbabwe; if he was a politician then even Mugabe’s motorcade will pull over to let him pass!

It was the mocking ZimAsset begging bowl and the fear of poverty’s growing power and influence that forced Mugabe to forgo his struggle hold on power and seek to share it in another GNU.

 The three interrelated questions to answer here are: What kind of power sharing would Mugabe want? What political solution would the nation want? And lastly, what kind of solution are we most likely to have?

When Rugare Gumbo announce Zanu PF’s willingness to talk he nailed the one condition that Mugabe wanted accepted and understood from the onset; drop all claims of Zanu PF rigging July 2013 elections. In other words Mugabe and Zanu PF must be accepted as legitimate and thus the government of the day.

Whatever political animal that will emerge from the proposed talks, Mugabe will want to have the final say in defining it and oversight of all it does.

By selecting his old partners in the GNU and, no doubt, only those in civic society who accept Zanu PF’s precondition will be allowed to take part in the talks; Mugabe is assured his hold on political power is secured. As for MDC leaders, most of them will only be too glad to get back on the gravy train. They will be some grandstanding and posturing but at the end of the day they will whatever role Mugabe assigns them.

The solution the nation would want is one that will end the economic meltdown and deport comrade poverty back wherever it was he comes from. GNU mark II will not address any of the fundamental economic weakness in Zimbabwe just as the first GNU of 2009 to 2013 failed to do because one cannot end corruption, for example, without dismantling the very foundations of Zanu PF’s political patronage system on which it depends.

The reason why Mugabe nailed the condition that Zanu PF is the legitimate government is because he did not want any of the democratic reforms designed to dismantle the Zanu PF dictatorship implemented.

After the formation of the first GNU in 2009, the then Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai visited most of the key Western countries’ capitals convinced they will bankroll Zimbabwe’s economic recovery. They were not convinced that Mugabe had changed contrary to Tsvangirai’s claims and so the sent the PM back empty handed.

There was evidence back then that Mugabe had not changed one bit; he was the same corrupt and murderous tyrant with no respect for the rule of law. Events that followed culminating in him rigging the 2013 elections showed just how naïve and incompetent Tsvangirai been to have been so easily bamboozled by Mugabe.

The international community’s position is simple enough, they will only engage with a legitimate government coming out of free and fair elections. None of the Western leaders will be fooled by the GNU mark II in which Mugabe has even more political power than before.

So the ideal solution would be for Mugabe to accept that he has failed to rig economic recovery and for him and Tsvangirai and their respect political parties to walk into the political sunset. The nation must then appoint an interim administration to implement all the political reforms and hold fresh free, fair and credible elections. The government to emerge will have the mandate of the people and legitimacy to govern and the support and goodwill of the international community.

It is not in the nature of tyrants to give up power even with a deadly adversary like poverty already running rings in one’s back yard. Mugabe will still pursue a meaningless power sharing arrangement with MDC in the hope of sharing the blame for the economic hardships and to buy time.

Zimbabwe has a lot of things, gold, diamonds and lots of other goodies beside but time is the one thing it does not have. The shortage of clean drinking water means the nation is sitting on a health time bomb. Poverty is causing untold human misery we are sitting on a ticking social time bomb. Anyone of these bombs or both could explode anytime. The consequences of such an outcome are catastrophic for us all!

Time is of the essence; only a democratically elected government can defuse these time bombs and it is important that such a government is elected a.s.a.p.

It should not be left to Mugabe to decide when Zimbabwe will finally have free and fair elections; he has kept the nation waiting for just that these last 34 years. He should not have a say in this time!

It should not be left to Tsvangirai and his MDC friends to implement the reforms, the prerequisite for free, fair and credible elections; they five years during the GNU but failed to get even one reform implemented. The only reason they failed was that they were easily bribed by Mugabe with the trappings of power and high office and that they are breathtakingly incompetent. It is folly for the nation to once again entrust such irresponsible individuals with the very survival of the nation!

Zimbabwe, each and every one of us wherever we are must step up and for once take full responsibility and demand that Mugabe and Tsvangirai step aside and allow others to take charge. Zimbabwe has a population of 12 million, it is bound to have the 20 or so competent to get the reforms implemented without having to rely Zanu PF who do not want any reforms implement or MDC who do not what reforms we are talking about.

In one of his great speeches former US President John F Kennedy said to the American people: “Do not ask what my country can do for me? Ask instead, what can I do for my country?” There will never be a better moment, with millions groaning in abject poverty and a devilish storm threatening, for Zimbabweans to do their best for their country before it is too late!

14 comments:

Zimbabwe Light said...

Power is a very strong and addictive drug, take it and you will feel there is nothing you cannot do but, worse still, you will do anything to get the next dose. And power is at its most potent when, like any other drug, it is taken in its most concentrated and purified form - absolute power.

"We were kind enough to offer them passports which they then used to travel to Britain to claim we were out to imprison them and yet fail to appreciate they were using Mugabe's passport," Mugabe said.

The tyrant was not just contend in claim the country was his, "my Zimbabwe" he is now going further and claiming all of us are his personal property too. It is time the tyrant is shown the exist door out of State House, the idiot should have been allowed there in the first place much less to stay for 34 years!

Zimbabwe Light said...

@ Roving Eagle

One of the most disappointing things about Zimbabwe is just how naive some people are. The reforms were to ensure free and fair elections; of course Zanu PF did not want free and fair elections and it should therefore be obvious that they would not want any reforms implemented. To therefore "blame" Zanu PF for the failure to have even one reform implemented only shows just how naive you are.

The only point Zanu PF would have tried to "block" the reforms was by Mugabe refusing to sign into law the proposed reforms passed by parliament. Mugabe never refused to sign anything because no proposed reforms were ever tabled or passed by parliament.

Mugabe knew that if he lied a honey trap for the MDC leaders, give them ministerial cars, gener-ous allowances and for Tsvangirai the highlands mansion plus lots of cash for him to chase women of ill repute to his heart's content, they will all forget about the reforms. And that is exactly what happened.

Mugabe also knew that MDC supporters like you were a confused lot who follow leaders blindly like sheep and therefore you will never notice that none of the reforms had been implemented. Even now with the benefit of hindsight you are still failing to grasp that MDC leaders betrayed the nation.

“Those reforms are cleaning zpf's deliberate messy,” you argue, showing just what a confused person you are. “Why the country has to spend invaluable resources cleaning after zpf ?” Yes Zanu PF created the mess but as long as the mess remains Zanu PF will continue to rig elections and stay in power. We want to end the corruption and political repression and the only way to end them is to end Zanu PF rule through free and fair elections.

In other words it is in the interest of free and fair elections and having a government that is democratically accountable to the people that we must implement the reforms and clean the Zanu PF mess! (This is like talking to five year old!)

Zimbabwe is in this political and economic mess because the nation has had the great misfor-tune of having a tyrant like Mugabe in power and a breathtakingly incompetent challenger like Tsvangirai; yes. But that is only the half of it.

The other half is that we have also had the great misfortune of having a breathtakingly naive electorate. As long as we continue to have an electorate that can be easily hoodwinked even by a village idiot then there is no chance of this nation ever getting out of this mess!

Zimbabwe Light said...

@ Mukandabhutsu

And what change have you achieved so far after five years in the GNU?

Democracy, the vote and freedom of expression these are all very sharp Samurai swords; in skilled hands they save lives but in the wrong hands will take hundreds of thousands of innocent lives! You have failed to realise that MDC have failed to deliver any change and yet you plough on heedless.

Of course it is your democratic right to follow blindly like a sheep it is just that the nation have paid dearly for that stupidity. What else did Tsvangirai have to do to finally open your eyes to the seriousness of MDC's failure to implement reforms?

"Isu we want change now", and yet you do not have clue of what that change it. Never did!

Zimbabwe Light said...

@ bobby

Unemployment is already seating at a nauseating 85% plus and every month more companies are closing down. Any of those sent back from UK, SA and Botswana will all go straight on the unemployment heap.

If Mugabe cannot see that this is a ticking social time bomb then he will see that soon enough when it goes off! It is the duty of everyone to see to it that the tyrant sees the danger because when that bomb goes off it will not take the tyrant and his regime alone but hundreds if not thousands of innocent Zimbabweans too.

Zimbabwe Light said...

Jacob Ngarivhume is right MDC should have never joined Mugabe to form the GNU in 2008 particularly with such a one-sided GPA in favour of Mugabe. Tsvangirai was warned against joining but when Mugabe dangled the keys of the ministerial Mercedes Benz in his face the tyrant had the village idiot hooked.

The opportunity to end the Zanu PF dictatorship there and then was lost when Tsvangirai signed the GPA in September 2008. Still there was sufficient scope in the GPA to dismantle the Zanu PF dictatorship if MDC had implemented the democratic reforms and produced a democratic constitution as called upon in the GPA.

The GNU was supposed to last 18 months in the end it lasted five years, enough time for all the democratic reforms to be fully implemented and a new democratic constitution written and passed; you would think! Not even one reform was ever implemented and the Copac constitution was weak and feeble it completely failed its maiden test – to deliver free, fair and credible elections.

MDC were warned against taking part in the elections without any reforms implemented but once again they paid no heed.

In the circumstance of joining the GNU and then failing to implement the reform, to say Tsvangirai lacks “strategic thinking” is an understatement; the man is a breathtakingly incompetent and a blundering village idiot!

The very fact that so many Zimbabweans were so easily con by this village idiot bespeaks volumes of lack of common sense amongst our people. The nation would have never allowed Mugabe to rule roughshod for 34 years now if we had not been fast asleep. We would have ensured that MDC implemented the reforms for a start and yet even now, with the benefit of hindsight, millions of Zimbabweans still do not have clue what the reforms are!

People get the government and opposition they deserve; we certainly deserve this corrupt and tyrannical Zanu PF regime and this incompetent MDC opposition!

Zimbabwe Light said...

@ Whichfool

Zanu PF is collapsing because the rabbis carrying vampire bats of 34 years of mismanagement and corruption have come home to roost. Poverty now rules the land; if poverty was a human being then even Mugabe's motorcade would pull over whilst poverty and his entourage passed.

A CIO report has warned Mugabe that his hold on power is as shaky as a fiddler on the roof be-cause of the threat of social unrest is real. Not only are ordinary people likely to riot in protest against the growing poverty and hopelessness but those in the security services are themselves set to riot. Soldiers are now being forced to take two months forced leave a very because the army cannot feed them, for example; it is naïve to think that these soldiers are going to put up with this for long, the report argue!

The CIO report told Mugabe he must to do something to get the economy back on track but what can the tyrant do?

He instituted a political system that was doomed to failure, the dye was cast years ago and it has since dried never to be washed out; all that can happen now is for the system to sink into oblivion in the cesspool of its own making.

Instead of bowing to the inevitable and accept his failure and step down; Mugabe is lashing out and blaming everyone but himself for the country’s economic meltdown. Lately he has taken to blaming the Zimbabwean in the diaspora, the victims of his corrupt rule, for the country's eco-nomic melt-down.

It is only by dismantling this failed Zanu PF dictatorship and thus end the criminal waste of hu-man and material resources that we have economic recovery. No amount of rhetorical denial or nonsense will ever get us out of this mess; we will only be wasting time whilst the nation sinks ever deeper in the cesspool!

You should read the CIO report for yourself. See http://www.bulawayo24.com/index-id-news-sc-national-byo-50827.html#sthash.8ra9a3iM.dpuf
S W Radio Africa gave the people of Zimbabwe the opportunity to think for themselves and to find their own voice. If the people have still not learn to think for themselves after 13 years and will still follow blindly like sheep then a life time of S W Radio Africa would have made no differ-ence!

As the Shona would say; “Chava chigondora chava chin’gombe, kutadza kutunga hurama hwacho!” Zimbabweans must now think for themselves!

The economic meltdown is real and it is posing an immediate and very serious challenge to the very stability and survival of the nation. It is incumbent on Zimbabweans themselves to think and implement a solution out of this mess or pay the consequences. It is no use expecting Mugabe to come up with the solution; it was the tyrant who landed the nation in all this mess, it is naïve to expect his to have the political will to get us out. Time is running out!

Zimbabwe Light said...

@ Mike Hondo

Mugabe can use the empty ZimAsset begging bowl to drink the champagne with Chimbwido; it will be the first time he would have put that mocking bowl to some used!

Zimbabwe is in serious trouble because Mugabe has failed to rig economic recovery. Yes the tyrant hated S W Radio Africa with a consuming passion and if this closure had come at some other time, he would have been very pleased. When you house is on fire, Zimbabwe is on fire right now, you hardly notice the deaths of rats no matter how much you hate the rats. At best the fire will destroy the rat’s nest whereas Mugabe is himself caught up in the raging inferno!

Zimbabwe Light said...

@ Cathy Buckle

S W Radio Africa is stopping its week day broadcast because of the financial squeeze affecting everyone else in Zimbabwe. We are all the victims of the economic meltdown hitting the country like one of those disasters brought on by El Nino or swarms of locust except that this economic meltdown in man-made, Mugabe-made. 34 years of gross mismanagement and rampant corruption have taken their toll of the Zimbabwe economy and now the economy is in ICU and poverty in everywhere.

S W Radio Africa did a great job retelling "our horror stories, lived with us through our anguish and cried with us at each inhumanity" as you said. But they also encourage us to think and look for the way out of this hell-on-earth Mugabe and Zanu PF were dragging us into.

The Shona have a saying; "Chava chigondora chava chi'gombe kutadza kutunga hurama hacho!" (A calf yearling with sprouting horns has only itself to blame if it cannot defend itself.) If Zimbabweans have not yet learnt to think for themselves out of man-made situation after 13 years of encouragement from S W Radio Africa then we only have ourselves to blame!

Zimbabwe’s economic meltdown is real; it hitting everyone very hard and, until something is done to get the national economy back on track, things are set to get even worse. If there was ever a time for Zimbabweans to wake up from their sloth-like slumber this is that time. The people are naïve to expect Mugabe and Zanu PF to led the nation out of this mess; it was the tyrannical regime that dragged the nation into this mess to gratify their insatiable appetite for power and wealth, only they care about now is how they are going to hang on to both in these turbulent days!

If Zimbabwe is ever going to get out of this hell-hole Mugabe landed us then it is the people themselves who will have to think of a way out and not Mugabe or Zanu PF. S W Radio Africa has done a great job in preparing the nation for this moment; if we fail them it is our own doing!

Zimbabwe Light said...

Tsvangirai tells members that he will give up power if he loses in the October party elections.

Tsvangirai has made so many monumental blunders, the fact that he is still leading the MDC be-speaks of the breath-taking incompetence within that party.

In 2004 the US Ambassador Chris Dell said Tsvangirai was a "flawed and indecisive character" it is amazing that after years of proving the Ambassador right many MDC leaders and supporters alike still cannot see this!

Whether we care to admit this or not the fact of the matter is a healthy and functioning democracy demands an electorate that has some common sense to learn from their past mistakes at least. The Zimbabwe electorate still has this herd mentality of following leaders without asking questions; in this case they will follow a village idiot like Tsvangirai even after he has proven beyond doubt that he is indeed a village idiot!

Zimbabwe Light said...

“There are young people who need to be taught that there are leaders who fought for the independence of this country. These young ones were never detained in prisons,” Mugabe said.

“Those who fought in the struggle have scars, others are visible while others are not.”

Mugabe’s comments were meant for the young Zanu PF members who have become increasingly restless to take up key leadership positions in the party. The party has a clause in the party constitution barring those who have not served consistently in the party at provincial level for a period of 15 years from contesting for positions in the central committee.

Although the statement is meant for the Zanu PF “young turks” it is even more applicable to all those outside the party who have dared challenge the party’s struggle hold on political power. Mugabe has viewed all those who have dared challenge Zanu PF’s hold on power as traitors and dealt with them and their supporters accordingly.

Ever since the country’s independence in 1980 the country is yet to hold free, fair and credible elections in which all Zimbabweans are granted a meaningful say in the govern-ance of the country. Over the years the regime has murdered over 30 000 innocent Zimbabweans to establish and maintain its de facto one-party dictatorship.

The right of every Zimbabwean to a meaningful say in the governance of the country was at the very heart of the fight for independence because it was only by securing this right that blacks could be assured of ending the white racist exploitation, oppression and denial of a fair share of the nation’s wealth. It is the failure by this Mugabe regime to grant this same right after independence that is the root cause of the economic and political injustices we see today.

Yes we all acknowledge that there are “who fought in the struggle have scars, etc.” but what we have been rejecting and will continue to reject in no uncertain term is that their contribution in the war of independence give them a right to deny any Zimbabwean their birth right to a free, fair and credible vote! To argue that it does is nonsense because that would be tantamount to every generation having to fight the generation before it to earn the free vote. No nation can accept and tolerate such continuous turmoil.

Zanu PF rigged the 2013 elections and the voters roll is the smoking gun to the rigged vote. The root cause of the country’s economic mess can be traced back to the rig elections and the only way to end the economic meltdown is for Mugabe and Zanu PF step-ping aside and allow the full implementation of all the democratic reforms and the holding of free, fair and credible elections.

It was the granting of special undemocratic privileges to a select few after independence that landed the nation in this political and economic mess, it is sad to note Mugabe has yet to realise this!

Zimbabwe Light said...

@ Jukwa

"As long as the old guard continues to guard the hard-won Chimurenga successes"? Who is to say which are the Chimurenga successes? The OLD GUARD! Who is to say the successes are being guarded? THE OLD GUARD! That is exactly what is wrong with the system, it does not grant everybody else other than those already in power any say in the governance of the country.

The Chimurenga war was for "One man, one vote!" and not this Mugabe stupid distortion of "One man one vote, but only with the old guard as the candidates"

Zimbabwe Light said...

@ Jukwa

The right to a meaningful say in the governance of the country is a birth right of every Zimba-bwean. So Mugabe rigged the 2014 elections just as he has done all the other elections before because all the millions of Zimbabweans he denied the vote did not "earn the vote"!

No wonder the tyrant is hiding the voters roll, the smoking gun to the rigged vote. Let me tell you here and now he is not getting away with the rigged elections, not this time.

The regime has murdered over 30 000 innocent Zimbabweans to establish and maintain this one-party dictatorship under cover of "hunting pale devils". The regime is collapsing because it is rotten to the core and all you thugs will have to account for all the blood on your hands!

The game is up, Jukwa; soon there will be nowhere for you to hide!

Zimbabwe Light said...

@ Ndini

MDC made a serious blunder if any opposition leader wants to be taken serious then he or she must show the voters that they are smart enough to know what blunders Tsvangirai made so they too do not make the same mistake.

The trouble with people like Chikombraz is that they have failed to see Tsvangirai for the blundering idiot he is and thus will vote for him again and again although he has failed to deliver anything in the past.

Try to explain to Chikombraz that it is not enough to just want Mugabe out; you must also get someone up to the task. They cannot grasp the argument! People like that a hard wired to follow leaders without questioning just like a wildebeest.

Man is supposed to be a thinking animal endowed with a superior brain than all the other animals; sadly the brain of many Zimbabweans has turned into unless fatty tissue after years of idleness. It is now impermeable to reason. It is little wonder the country is in a mess!

Zimbabwe Light said...

@GM

I failed to see what you are trying to say here.

“The international community will not drop a cent into Zimbabwe because the types of William Mukori have been included in any talks about Zimbabwe's future. Instead the international community want a return of national confidence in the government before they can engage. Without that national confidence NO twenty Mukoris can move the international community to move any inch in engaging Zimbabwe,” you said.

In the first sentence: 1) there have not been any talks so I have been included in talks that are not there and 2) the international community have not contributed a penny into the ZimAsset begging bowl for other reasons and not because of imaginary participants in imaginary talks.

In the second sentence: if there is one thing Mugabe has never lacked it is self-confidence and so if it was just “a return of national confidence” then after the rigged elections Mugabe and Zanu PF were agog with self-confidence. It was the international community that did not have confidence in the regime to end corruption and to respect the rule of law. After you have just rigged an election, it was of course impossible to hold yourself as a paragon of rule of law.

In the third sentence: well there is so much confusion here one does not even know where to start to try and unravel it. Can you please explain what will restore this mythical “national confidence”; forget about the 20 Mukoris, they have played no part in this.